Terence gorman, community preference fields, econometrica 21 1953. Temporal aggregation bias and mixed frequency estimation of a new keynesian model job market paper tae bong kim this version. The econometrics of aggregation is about modelling the relationship between individual micro. In our model sample selection bias arises when the residual in the selection equation i. This study uses monte carlo analysis to evaluate the usefulness of kelejians test. The econometrics of aggregation refers to modelling with the individualaggregate connection in mind, creating a framework where information on individual behaviour together with comovements of aggregates can be used to estimate a consistent econometric model. Temporal aggregation bias and inference of causal regulatory. In statistics, bias is an objective property of an estimator. One of the very important roles of econometrics is to provide the tools for modeling on the basis of given data. The aggregation problem is the difficult problem of finding a valid way to treat an empirical or theoretical aggregate as if it reacted like a lessaggregated measure, say, about behavior of an individual agent as described in general microeconomic theory.
Under what condition, the ols estimator suffers from ovb. February, 2020 comments welcome 1this manuscript may be printed and reproduced for individual or instructional use, but. An efficient method of estimating seemingly unrelated regressions and tests for aggregation bias. In econometrics, something called the simultaneity occurs when a variable on the righthand side of the casual inferential model equation and the variable on the lefthand side of the same model equation influence each other at the same time. Aggregation bias estimating demand with aggregate data often leads to model misspecification, or aggregation bias. Aggregation, distribution and dynamics in the linear and. In this paper, we seek to bridge this gap by formalizing the tradeoff between data aggregation i. Spatial and temporal aggregation in the estimation of labor. In statistics, the bias or bias function of an estimator is the difference between this estimators expected value and the true value of the parameter being estimated. Theil, linear aggregation of economic relations amsterdam. Aggregation bias in maximum likelihood estimation of spatial autoregressive processes tony e.
They exist at virtually every level, from the initial issues of data construction and model specication to the subsequent issues. So is the value of one randomly selected observation. Nov 9, 2010 abstract this paper asks whether frequency misspecication of a new keynesian model results in temporal aggregation bias of the calvo parameter. A variety of technical and theoretical explanations of the socalled aggregation problem in correlation and regression and some solutions have been offered.
Regression analysis with crosssectional data 21 chapter 2 the simple regression model 22 chapter 3 multiple regression analysis. Statistics, econometrics and forecasting by arnold zellner. Aggregation problems are more than a cloying annoyance in empirical work. Aggregation bias is also observed in econometric estimations e. In these examples, yimight be wages and xicould include gender, race. An efficient method of estimating seemingly unrelated. Make sure you read your book to get all the details and none of us will claim any responsability if you up your ps or final you are supposed to learn this with. More significantly, aggregation bias is very large relative to the gains from liberal trade. However, policy is most often set at a more aggregate level. Product aggregation bias as a specification error in. Aggregation bias and ecological fallacy researchers need to design their studies at the appropriate unit of analysis.
Examples of aggregates in micro and macroeconomics relative to less. Practical models must address three types of individual heter. This paper seeks to fill this key gap in the forest. Econometric analysis of aggregation in the context of linear jstor. Pierse testing for aggregation bias in linear models 4 this theorem provides an asymptotic justi cation for the use of q 2 in testing the null hypothesis of no aggregation bias, and holds for. The aim of this note is to interpret estimation of the conventional treatmenteffect selection bias model in econometrics as a method of aggregation and to draw the implications of this. An estimator or decision rule with zero bias is called unbiased. If fx is linear then 4x1 0 and there is no aggregation bias.
Arnold zellner an e cient method of estimating seemingly unrelated regressions and tests for aggregation bias journal of the american statistical association, 1962 di erent regression equations that seem to be unrelated and. It is important to examine the possibility of such errors before estimating the model. Estimation 68 chapter 4 multiple regression analysis. The sample mean is an estimator of the population mean. Time aggregation and the distributional shape of unemployment. Smith department of systems engineering university of pennsylvania philadelphia, pa 19104 october 16, 2001 abstract in statistical models of spatial behavior, there is often a mismatch between the scale at which data is available and the scale at.
In a typical experiment, scientists use microarrays to measure the abundance of mrna at discrete time points after the onset of a stimulus. This is especially important to understand so that one can avoid making improper inferences about units of analysis that were not actually analyzed. Bessler this study proposes one plausible procedure to address two methodological issues. Kelejian 1994 provides a methodology for testing for the presence of this form of bias. Pdf selection bias adjustment in treatmenteffect models as. We cover recent empirical demand models, and present aggregation factors computed from data on british households. Econometrics deals with the measurement of economic relationships. Endogenous variables xi and yi are determined within the system. Econometrics, presented at the european meeting of the econometric society. Econometrics chapter 1 introduction to econometrics shalabh, iit kanpur 5 econometrics and regression analysis. There is an emerging literature that investigates the sources of media bias mullainathan and shleifer 2005, baron 2004, gentzkow and shapiro 2005.
Whats aggregation bias, and how does it relate to the. Inference 118 chapter 5 multiple regression analysis. First, it clarifies the meaning of aggregation bias and its applicability to the ppp puzzle. Second, the size of the bias is shown to be much smaller than the simulations in imbs et.
Continuous time econometrics a new zealand contribution temporal aggregation, selective sampling of timeseries data. Bias there are lots and lots of estimators, but not all are equally good. Attenuation bias if we perform the regression of y. Such sources of aggregation introduces aggregation bias. Inherent in all demand studies is some form of product aggregation which can lead to product aggregation bias. Temporal aggregation bias and inference of causal regulatory networks abstract timecourseexperimentswith microarrayshavebegun to providea glimpse into the dynamic behavior of gene expression. Recent progress on aggregation and econometrics has centred on explicit. As we shall see, sample selection bias can be viewed as a special case of endogeneity bias, arising when the selection process generates endogeneity in the selected subsample. Aggregation in the futures markets is a principal involving the combination of all future positions owned or controlled by a single trader or group of traders. Department of economics, university of victoria, canada. Under what condition, ols estimator suffers from ovb. It is an integration of economics, mathematical economics and statistics with an objective to provide numerical values to the parameters of economic relationships. Floyd university of toronto july 22, 20 this document outlines the nature of simultaneity bias in regression analysis and the standard method for dealing with it, twostage least squares.
The regression modeling technique helps a lot in this task. Environmental econometrics gr03 endogeneity fall 2008 12 27. Pdf accounting for aggregation bias in almost ideal. An application of the theory of generalized inverses. Evaluating potential sources of aggregation bias with a. Accounting for aggregation bias in almost ideal demand. Econometrics is a method of causal inference applied to economics. February, 2020 comments welcome 1this manuscript may be printed and reproduced for individual or instructional use, but may not be printed for commercial purposes. In terms of empirical research in economics, this means facing and resolving aggregation problems. In particular, this type of bias is manifested as the inflation of macrolevel coefficient estimates above the corresponding values of these coefficients estimated from microlevel data. A000234 aggregation econometrics the econometrics of aggregation is about modelling the relationship between individual micro behaviour and aggregate macro statistics, so that data from both levels can be used for estimation and inference about economic parameters. This is where the estimators sampling distribution comes in it tells.
Testing for aggregation bias in a nonlinear framework. The econometrics of aggregation is about modelling the relationship between individual micro behaviour and aggregate macro statistics, so that data from both levels can be used for estimation and inference about economic parameters. Department of economics, university of victoria, canada the. Endogenous and exogenous variables suppose a more general model.
Consistent trade policy aggregation boston college. The use of high dimensional panel data in micro econometrics and macro econometrics. Econometric analysis of aggregation in the context of linear. The formulation of the problems of best approximate aggregation and disaggregation presented in the chapter. Department of economics, university of victoria, canada the econometrics of temporal aggregation. Attenuation bias happens when you run a regression where you have y on the left side and y and x on the right side because you have y twice you are attenuating the effect of x.
With the decreasing level of tariffs due to the increasing number of economic unions or free trade agreements ftas, the importance of nontariff barriers ntbs in trade has risen. Temporal aggregation bias and inference of causal regulatory networks stephen bay, 1lonnie chrisman, andrew pohorille, 2 and jeff shrager 1 institute for the study of learning and expertise 2164 staunton court, palo alto, ca 94306 2 center for computational astrobiology and fundamental biology nasa ames research center, ms 2394, moffett field, ca 94305. Time aggregation does not seem to have drastic effects on the estimates in a simple parametric model like the weibull, but can produce dramatic changes in the more complicated extended generalized gamma model. Under conditions generally encountered in practice, it is found that the regression coefficient estimators so obtained are at least asymptotically more efficient. As in our model, mullainathan and shleifer 2005 assume that media bias is caused by preference for con. Accounting for aggregation bias in almost ideal demand systems article pdf available in journal of agricultural and resource economics 2102. The problem of aggregation over micro units has been approached in the empirical literature from a number of di erent viewpoints. Another issue of interest is the earnings gap between men and women. Since this problem is widely known, we do not detail why aggregation bias. Aggregation bias to motivate the issue of aggregation bias, it is informative to consider the classic examples offered by theil 1 1954 and gorman2 1953. If there is confounding, then the difference for group and individual effects is a combination of confounding and aggregation bias. Bias can also be measured with respect to the median, rather than the mean expected value, in. Econometrics chapter 1 introduction to econometrics shalabh, iit kanpur 1 chapter 1 introduction to econometrics econometrics deals with the measurement of economic relationships.
Knox lovell university of north carolina, chapel hill, mc, u. The effects of data aggregation in statistical analysis wiley online. Aggregation bias in estimates of perceptual agreement. Regression has been overed as evidence of liability under title vii of the civil rights act of 1964,1 as evidence of racial bias in death penalty litigation,2 as evidence of damages in contract actions,3 as evidence of. They are all trying to make you give the wrong answer in your undergrad ps. One can learn about the nature of aggregation bias by studying the factors pmt and pzt. For this comparison it is necessary to control for the terms of trade effect. Pdf modeling marketing dynamics by time series econometrics. Introduction every field of economics uses aggregated data to test hypotheses about the behavior of individuals. Empirical results empirical results in table 2 include cts original within estimates in column 1 and our. Pdf on aggregation bias in structural demand models.
Omitted variable bias population regression equation true world suppose we omitted x 1i and estimated the following regression. Such sources of aggregation introduce aggregation bias in the estimates of the coefficients. Pdf selection bias adjustment in treatmenteffect models. Seemingly unrelated regressions in panel models presented by catherine keppel, michael anreiter and michael greinecker. Aggregation bias in the economic model of crime todd l. Using 50 units, populated by, 100, and 10,000 individuals, we find that aggregation bias is almost universally present.
Increasingly, they have become important to lawyers and legal policy makers as well. A000234 aggregation econometrics the econometrics of aggregation is about modelling the relationship between individual micro behaviour and aggregate macro statistics, so that data. This chapter discusses a linear regression model in which x is the n. Temporal aggregation bias and mixed frequency estimation of a. Aggregation bias in almost ideal demand systems 249 where eai 1, y j, yi, p 0 y, ij i vi j, i i j i and kh 0, vh, are taste difference parameters allowing for different preference relations across households. Forecasting performance modelling with mixed data frequencies. Estimating promotional effects with retailerlevel scanner. In ecological studies, aggregation bias is the expected difference between effects for the group and effects for the individual, if there is no confounding. Aggregation bias is large, using trade weighted as opposed to consistently aggregated tariffs overstates real income for india by nearly 1%. The ecological fallacy consists in thinking that relationships observed for groups necessarily hold for individuals.
A minimal requirement on an estimator is consistency, i. The fundamental issue to consider when worrying about sample selection bias is why some individuals will not be included in the sample. To me, the term bias indicates that by aggregation i should be systematically pushing the results to either overestimate or underestimate the size of relationships. The problem of aggregation over micro units has had a long tradition in the econometrics literature, stretching back to the pioneering work of theil 1954. Hansen 2000, 20201 university of wisconsin department of economics this revision. This article develops a simple procedure for incorporating product aggregation bias in demand systems that permits testing of product aggregation bias with a standard likelihood ratio test. Northholland publishing company a note on aggregation bias and loss c.
1554 1367 1119 112 1097 736 909 207 262 816 937 641 60 1521 367 133 894 516 220 1455 1527 1537 1376 1478 476 1063 1442 1245 1131 38 544 918 1108 193 1058 777 412 1361 378 980 50 1014 650 968 1050 361